Friday, October 29, 2010

Rejection of the Primacy and Titles for the Pope

It was not until 325 AD during the Council of Nicaea that there was any primacy assigned to the Roman see. Julius, the bishop of the Roman see, was not present at this council, but his representatives were given a fourth place rank at the council. Calvin then asks the question, "if Julius had been recognized as the head of the church, why were his delegates relegated to fourth place?" Even 124 years later at the Second Council of Ephesus, the patriarch of Alexandria was over the council, not the patriarch of Rome. This indicates to us that the patriarch of Rome did not hold first place over all other bishops.

At the Council of Chalcedon, the emperor allowed the representatives of Rome to have the highest seat. Leo had requested this position. His reasoning was that the bishops from the East had caused unnecessary conflict at the Council of Ephesus. After this council, the Roman representatives did not hold the top chair at the following councils.

The early church did not recognize the primacy of the bishop of Rome or the Roman see. Cyprian, who was the 3rd century bishop of Carthage, called Cornelius, the bishop of Rome, "brother," "fellow bishop," and "colleague." He gave no indication in his letters that Cornelius held any higher position than any other bishop. At the Council of Carthage, it was decided that no one should ever be called "prince of priests" or "first bishop." The bishop of Rome could be referred to as "bishop of the prime see." Jerome, the 4th-5th century translator of the Bible into Latin, spoke out against the idea of the authority of one bishop over all others.

The late 6th century Gregory the Great was opposed to the title "universal bishop" or "ecumenical bishop." He thought that this was profane, sacrilegious, and the precursor of Antichrist. He said, "The whole church falls from its condition if anyone who is called 'universal' falls." Gregory was highly critical of anyone wishing to gain this or any similar title. He wrote, "No one ever wished to be called by such a name; no one seized upon this presumptuous title lest, by snatching to himself in the pontifical rank the glory of uniqueness, he should seem to deny it to all his brethren."

Tomorrow's reading: 4.7.5-4.7.10


  1. I wanted to say that it's nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same info elsewhere.

  2. Why does he fight in the name of religion? Will the Lord whom man worships and fights for, enjoys and takes happiness in these religious fights?guarantor

  3. Extremely disappointed, she realized it would never happen, and quit the profession. She also gave up her belief in a personal God, and turned to the study of religion as her god.
    learn more about Sacral Chakra

  4. I had a real problem finding this post! Thanks for the submitted report! It's education! Awesome stuff!

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. This is a truly good site post. Not too many people would actually. the way you just did. I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject that have been uncovered and you’ve done your best. with so much class. If wanted to know more about green smoke reviews. than by all means come in and check our stuff. best nespresso machine

  7. There is nobody immaculate coffee maker that has everything; there are simply coffee makers that can be ideal for you, in view of which elements you acknowledge and esteem the most.this

  8. Vacuum espresso creators are additionally increasing a great deal of notoriety nowadays. This machine is made with two glass compartments present, one over the other. A significant safeguard to take while purchasing this sort of machine is to check the glass type.
    brew man

  9. Not surprisingly, busy people tend to like the convenience of single-cup coffee machines, because they have portability in that they can take their cups of coffee with them straight after hair honey

  10. I really enjoyed your article, if you wish feel free to check my post about @: Best Coffee Maker For Americano! Thanks for sharing


Presbyterian Bloggers
Powered By Ringsurf